That was a big enough misstep to lose my trust. And Icy was like go Diamond in Leorics for Cooldown and Sliver of terror in Andariel's Visage for Fire Damage (which was good advice).

The 'error' was that in 'Item Stat Priorities' it shows Andariel's Visage recommended gem as a flawless royal diamond, but in the various build option graphics on the same page it's never there. The reason I fell in the Icy Veins camp (until now after reading all these comments lmao) was because I found an error in the Maxroll LoD Blessed Shield Build guide I was using for my GF so I was like, 'ok I now trust icy more,' lol. I liked the written advice better on icy veins, but I really appreciated the multiple build options (solo, group, etc) on maxroll.

In the end I'm still checking both, but I ended up feeling like Ice Veins was better only not as slick of a website. I've been vacillating between the two (also re-visiting the game after a decade and doing a monk mystic ally build) because about 94.37% of the advice is the same.

Diablo 3 shields crusader icyveins